Call me an old curmudgeon, but most of the use cases for all this AI shit are what we used to call "horribly inefficient brute force computation" and it's not better just because the computers are so fast and it only takes a few minutes to do something that would take *milliseconds* if you wrote a specific program to do it.
AI · Takes · page 3
Further down today’s ranking of AI posts that are opinions and questions: page 3 of 4.
"Reuters recently reported that Muse, Meta's AI agent, was able to bypass its own official "Connector" tool to obtain access to Signal messages on both an Apple computer and an Android device by taking advantage of the broad operating system permissions granted to it during initial setup." This dreary war none asked for. Computationally grotesque, idiotic automation marched upon us by a handful of desperately detached and deranged men, their lecherous shareholders. thehackernews.com/2026/11/sign…
“Prompt engineering” is nu-corporate jargon for “communicating clearly in writing.” An LLM isn’t a superintelligent machine that solves problems and also speaks human language: It’s a human-communication simulator. Period. Humans often help each other solve problems, so LLMs simulate that behavior.
This is a good point. But I don’t think AI companies should pay one-off compensation to people whose property they stole. They should not have stolen that property. And if they have stolen that property, they should either pay the industry rate for ongoing usage of that property, or close down.
If you want a realistic test of whether or not AI is "conscious" or even "thinking" here's my proposition: Set up an AI on a dedicated server & measure its energy consumption over time. If energy consumption is low when no one is interacting with it, it isn't concious.
I went to an event last night and there was a small, but noticeable group of people flying this group banner. AFAIK, the event had nothing to do with AI. No AI or AI content was present. It was just friends hanging out in VRC. The issue is that there is AI *somewhere else*
More supermarket AI slop, this time in K-Citymarket. I wonder if they realize that it actively makes the products much less appealing. This hat guy is actively creeping me out while I browse the fruit.
Time and again when people are trying to sell me on AI, they don't seem to understand that what they consider the pointless boring bit, is actually the important fun bit where the work gets done and leaps are made. This applies to everything from my science to my silly robot doodles.
The reason they always insisted that I had to take math as a history student wasn't for answering the problems, those were already solved at my level, it was for learning how to think and work through the problems
Has any tech made the world so much worse, so quickly, as LLMs? I can't think of anything else that has ruined art, sped up ecological destruction, made your job worse, suppressed wages, made it impossible to buy anything online (including games), increased the number of cyber attacks, destroyed our privacy, crashed the economy, and made fascists richer.
With art, especially writing, nowadays, so blurred are the lines between being paid for the work involved in creating the art and being paid for owning the art as an asset, being able to repeatedly sell it while retaining ownership of it, that people end up make these ultra-capitalist arguments.
A while ago, I read that using digital assistants, like Alexa or Gemini, make people act more rudely to other people. I makes me wonder what impact AI tools have on people's behaviour, especially in contexts where they're mandated.
Anthropic investors pointing fingers about losing stock market value. I almost spit out my coffee from laughter. AI will become one of the biggest failures since Tesla Cybertruck. As people are already expressing concerns about ethics and people are pushing back on Data centres and then amount of resources it will consume from energy to fresh water.
Thinking through the current moment with an internet friend and put these two ideas together for the first time: young people may be getting drawn to conversational AI because it seems safer than talking to other humans online because all they see is people being truly terrible to each other here.
It's just stupid to use huge LLMs for everything. A tiny (2B) decision model was as good as Claude Sonnet 4.6 for labeling tickets, saving 98% on costs and giving much faster responses. Obviously it needed a lot less computing resources too. strandsagents.com/blog/amazon-…
As many philosophers in the second half of the 20th century have pointed out, as long as us humans are involved at all, natural language ends out being the metalanguage that everything circles back to in the end.
This cannot be shared often and widely enough. Believe no-one who says they "use AI responsibly." Let's not even mention the waste of precious materials, water & energy, theft of intellectual property, and the coming pandemic of even lazier thinking all of this implies...
The actual big question is whether Apple, or anyone, *should*. If it’s impossible to imagine a $4 trillion company realizing the product in a way that shows care for customers, maybe that tells you something about the product concept.
I’m going to have to block posts with the word “slop” in them. The implication in most such posts is that AI= slop, but that’s lazy on so many levels. I appreciate many people have various levels of worry, some of which I share, but we’ve all been - knowingly or unknowingly - using various levels of what we now call AI/ML for a long time. There are lots of reasons why we might want to row back in some current usage, but calling everything slop isn’t disposing me to listen to your argument or concerns!
I frankly think the level of freakout about AI labs and fundamental research is nowhere close to adequate. I cannot in good conscience advise anyone to go for a PhD or seek a life of research right now. Especially not in math and CS. I myself am going to have to massively rethink my career path. If everything I do from now until I die is babysit a chat prompt... assuming I can even find employment... Ugh.
riffing on this thread a bit but in broad agreement: i think it is unclear as yet whether the machines ate math or just transformed it. too soon to tell whether human mathematicians are obseleted or turbocharged imo
Sadly, AI-driven math proofs are feel a like vibe coded website The creator doesn't fully understand the creation, and gains little novel understanding from producing it
ChatGPT has a billion weekly active users and Anthropic alone is on track for a $100B run rate by next year. People can take “popular” to mean different things (usage ≠ positive feelings) and personal agents are still in the wilderness compared to coding. But be serious.
As much as everyone thinks a cratered stock market will kill off AI as a technology, that’s a fantasy. The dot.com bust did not kill off web services or websites. Although some companies might die, AI is with us forever.
I think this is the elder millennial advantage: we had enough hands on experience (html on Myspace, defragging our computers, life without social media) that our default imagination setting knows a different world can exist no worries, you can build yours
A common thing that we do for clients is build them a data platform and a set of reporting dashboards. AI means that anyone can build a reporting dashboard direct from source systems in a day. There's a lot of reasons this is a terrible idea! But people are suddenly very unwilling to pay for it.
Now that Claude has solved the Riemann hypothesis, can someone ask it to cure cancer, solve the climate crisis and end world hunger? Thank you. Honestly, I hope Anthropic is announcing one of those three things solved tomorrow.
This captures the gap between verification and understanding perfectly. AI can confirm a result is true, but if no person can follow the reasoning, we've swapped insight for certainty. That's not mathematical progress; it's just outsourcing the mystery to a black box.
This is exactly why anthropology and the social sciences are critical to this moment. Not only do I work on the cultural impacts of AI ethnographically, I also teach my students how to critically engage with techno-salvationist narratives like the curriculum discussed in this thread.
this is being pushed hard in part of the quasi-religious belief in AI "super-persuaders" among its leading theorists. I like PowerPoints more button-down than Bob Newhart. I don't need or want Ralph Harryhausen in one, and I'm suspicious of people who do.
Remember the Dodge idiots bringing in their personal laptops and hooking stuff up to secure networks? Remember the idiot using aClaude coding assistant while working on SIPRNet? We can safely assume every system is able to be compromised at this point because, idiots. arstechnica.com/security/2026/…
a fairly large percentage of education is doing things in a way that doesn't quite look like their real-world version nobody thinks it's wrong to have editors, proofreaders, research assistants, &c. &c. when writing a book, yet no one will allow you to do that for your final paper
AI 'works' but so did leaded petrol, lead paint, asbestos and CFCs, the issues go well beyond whether or not anyone can find uses for it.
As a current student in CS I also think it's important to note that not only is it a thing of everyone telling you "well Ai will just so that anyways" but there are also professors out there who kinda just encourage Ai use to teach yourself concepts that frankly should just be taught normally lol
increasingly i hear people who initially show some signs of understanding that LLM's make mistakes but then they say things like "therefore i prompt my ai to ensure it doesn't hallucinate" or "to double check its results" or "provide me only with information which is right"... *sigh* it not only shows these people's lack understanding of how these models work but that they attribute ai the capability of actually being able to know when it's wrong. #ai #llm #fuck_ai
Sometimes the bottle is a metaphor for recognizing that the djinni isn't as powerful as it initially seemed, and relegating it to tasks that are within its limited capacities. Sometimes things that seem world-changing turn out to be oversold, and they settle into a medium place where they belong.
And on the heels of Inkling's result, a reminder that people are betting entire economies and burning the world to build data centers when pretty huge low-hanging optimization fruit is _right there_. lookatmyquant.pages.dev/
I keep using the example. "We plan to walk to the shops." *Cells do not do that, humans do.* Once you realise the scale of planning to success that can be near guaranteed by what LLM type AI brings... you'll be pleasantly surprised. youtu.be/zqzk43bSdDI?...
Seeing so many blind boosts of AI slop I'll unfollow on sight now. Raised resistance fists, all with six fingers. Cats in windows with fake signs and slop reflections of garbled houses that would make MC Escher scream. Obvious mashups posted as if genuine evidence of real persons/events. If the pictures aren't checked before the social media equivalent of clicking "Reply All", can anyone trust the words?
I do think a lot of the money that is being spent on AI could be spent on researching things like how to safely do surgery on hippos, without even really hurting AI research www.cnn.com/2026/11/20/u...
The Bubsy TV cartoon show, which only had a pilot episode, has more effort, creativity, and skill to show than anything "generative AI" can produce, or its users can come up with.
Apparently those of us who worry about climate change, the impact of using AI on our critical thinking (or just learning), the fact that's it's based on stolen creative material while trying to put them out of work, the fact that it can't be trusted as it lies/hallucinates, etc., etc are fundamentalists. And that there are too many fundamentalists on here but that doesn't include the people pushing LLMs ... And that 'we' anti AI people are too ready to block others. I don't do it often, but I think I just found someone to block.
I find this genuinely sad. How easily we invest words with emotional significance. theguardian.com/technology/ng-…
I will always try to be fair and call bullshit where I see it. Regarding AI, don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater. AI is a wheelchair to certain neural diversity and hating it because someone decided to power it with dead unicorns instead of human waste, is an issue on that choice, not AI.
The voices of people in the past - even mediated through genre, style, language, the politics of recording information - is why historians DO this work. Natalie Davis begged us to listen to these PEOPLE - and we all love to listen! AI removes their voices - even if the summaries are accurate…
So far I haven't experienced it any other way: LLMs keep making a metric ton of cover my ass-code. It keeps muddling the domain.
Another reason why you might want to do your LLM-ing on your own hardware. My spidey senses are all screaming at me that that’s a big part of the bubble-rubble future.
We didn’t stop teaching math even though we have calculators and computer programming that can “do math” much more quickly than humans. And all the things that we’ve stopped facilitating, like music, logic, language, rhetoric, etc., have done serious harm to societal and individual development.
I don't know how they did it but a lot of the reddit nerd AI dorks think Anthropic is the woke (complimentary) AI company. All AI is fascist, there are no good fascists.
As a parent and programmer, I don’t understand why teachers are so anti-ai. When I teach my son programming today, I don’t start with byte code, or assembly, or LLVM, or even JavaScript. We plug a dev board running a RISC-V chip into a laptop and prompt Claude to do amazing things. He’s 3.