Wildroot

Queries may use an external AI service. Details

Wildroot Browser

TopicsAITakes

AI · Takes

186 posts in AI that are opinions and questions, where the model is sure of the intent. Page 1 of 4: the top 17, then 24 the model is less sure belong here.

Ranked Bluesky · Mastodon

About 7 in 10 posts here get an intent label; the model only labels the ones it is sure of.

How it worksBuild a feed from AI · Takes

  1. “The economist Sendhil Mullainathan, in writing about the dangers of AI, cited the long-tail phenomenon (which I described in chapter 6) in his notion of 'tail risk’:” «We should be afraid. Not of intelligent machines. But of machines making decisions that they do not have the intelligence to make. I am far more afraid of machine stupidity than of machine intelligence. Machine stupidity creates a tail risk. Machines can make many many good decisions and then one day fail spectacularly on a tail event that did not appear in their training data. This is the difference between specific and general intelligence.»

    Show more of this post

    “Or as the AT researcher Pedro Domingos so memorably put it, 'People worry that computers will get too smart and take over the world, but the real problem is that they're too stupid and they've already taken over the world.’” #MelanieMitchell wrote this in 2019. It’s 2026 and I have not seen any improvement in this regard: no advancement in building systems that understand rather than mimic, and hence remain fragile to the long tail of events absent from the training data. #AI #LLMs

    Opinion
  2. @AeonCypher@lgbtqia.space

    I know that most of you don't care but the claim that #Claude (an #LLM #AI) solved the #RiemannHypothesis is really a wild exaggeration on multiple levels, and people keep posting about how it means we already have #ASI. Zzzzz. First, it's not actually confirmed it solved the #MilleniumMath problem. There is a team working through it to validate the results, and it will be months before we know. Why? Because it's a 220,000 page paper to prove it. The _only_ thing we've proven is that there's a Lean compilable proof of it, which means it has to be encoded correctly. Also, the team has already demonstrated that ***significant*** portions of the proof are superfluous.

    Show more of this post

    Additionally, a human (a human mathematician) was heavily involved in working with Claude to come up with the proof. Finally, a human actually proved it before Claude (probably). The thing is that a human would never publish work like this, it would be embarrassing. The only reason we think a human has solved it is that Claude's proof is forcing them into premature publication. There has not, in spite of what you may have heard, been some big breakthrough in AI; we do not have #AGI. What has happened is that we have harnesses that are good at causing an LLM to loop until it finds a proof. They are convergent optimizers when given infinite tokens. Which is A HUGE ACHIEVEMENT, but the reporting on them is wildly misleading.

    Opinion
  3. @timwatson.bsky.social

    There are lots of complicated questions about legal and financial liability for harms caused by AI. And then there is the simple clarity of Citibank's new user agreement for online banking: yes, You are liable.

    Screenshot of the new section H in the Citi Online User Agreement, which reads in part: H. Use of Third-party Artificial Intelligence (“AI”) Agents. If you provide your Online Credentials to any third-party AI Agent or otherwise permit such agent access to your accounts or allow such agent to use any digital service and to perform any transactions on your behalf, Citi will consider any access and actions taken by the agent as authorized by You. If the Online Credentials that you provided to the third-party AI Agent are further shared, leaked, or otherwise distributed to other persons or AI agents, Citi will consider any access and actions taken with the Online Credentials as authorized by You. Citi shall have no responsibility or other obligation to investigate the authority or validity of any such actions even if the actions taken by the agent or other person or AI agent with your Online Credentials conflict with any prompts or other instructions provided by You or on your behalf to
    Opinion
  4. @futurebird@sauropods.win

    On the day of Anthropic's IPO a group of people gathered to protest at their offices. These people are concerned that Anthropic is implementing "recursive self improvement" recklessly. And, I'm annoyed at them. Since most people don't pay much attention to the details of technical news about software... their complaint blends in with those who think LLMs are being implemented recklessly for less exotic reasons. It almost feels like deliberate misinformation designed to muddle the debate.

    OpinionPopular today
  5. One of the interesting parts of the "LLMs do certain kinds of code well" outcome is that other types of synthetic reasoning also become cheaper and get used more. SAT solvers are *very* capable, but they're famously hard to use. Now you can use them too, without tons of practice on translation work.

    Opinion
  6. LLMs were trained on massive (stolen) libraries of written formal English, not on informal spoken language. Result: writers with more traditional “proper English” writing styles (including ESL writers) get flagged as AI and penalized for that - authorship doubted, documents dismissed as spam/fake.

    Opinion
  7. @inthehands@hachyderm.io

    A specific form of this that irks me: I occasionally hear people framing debates around AI as whether the technology is “moving too fast” and needs to “slow down.” That comes from bad faith industry actors looking for a regulatory moat, but also from good faith thinkers trying to chart a path. Either way, that is the same trick as the quoited conversation here. My concern is not the •speed• of AI development, it’s the •direction•.

    Opinion
  8. @thebleats.by86400.link

    Speaking of sudden obvious realizations (not the quoted skeet) but AI does all the “fun stuff” because there’s orders of magnitude more data available documenting it. The promise is: You were doing this anyway for the love of the game, let a computer do it so you can focus on things you hate

    Opinion
  9. @scottgal@hachyderm.io

    Re-reading for the millionth time, reminded that the end point for AI should be local AI devices which make our kids revolutionaries (A Young Lady's Illustrated Primer).

    Neal Stephenson's book "The Diamond Age" depicts a lone figure walking toward a brilliant light at the end of a long road, framed by a red and orange, starburst-like background.
    Opinion
  10. @socratetris.bsky.social

    One of the struggles of generative algorithms in games/code is that a lot of coders don't think of their practice as an artform worth treating as a creative act. They have the engineering mindset of solve-problem-move-on. One of the earliest game studies articles was precisely about the artistry of

    Opinion
  11. The anxiety over vibe coding is eerily familiar to the 1980s anxiety of using other people's code #AI #VibeCoding

    Case 1 concerns a compiler. It has been developed by a group A for a Language L and worked very well on computer X. Now another group B has the task to write a compiler for a language L + M, a modest extension of L, for computer Y. Group B decides that the compiler for L developed by group A will be a good starting point for their design, and get a contract with group A that they will get support in the form of full documentation, including annotated program texts and much additional written design discussion, and also personal advice. The arrangement was effective and group B managed to develop the compiler they wanted. In the present context the significant issue is the importance of the personal advice from group A in the matters that concerned how to implement the extensions M to the language. During the design phase group B made suggestions for the manner in which the extensions should be accommodated and submitted them to group A for review. In several major cases it turned out tIn the years following these events the compiler developed by group B was taken over by other programmers of the same organization, without guidance from group A. Information obtained by a member of group A about the compiler resulting from the further modification of it after about 10 years made it clear that at that later stage the original powerful structure was still visible, but made entirely ineffective by amorphous additions of many different kinds. Thus, again, the program text and its documentation has proved insufficient as a carrier of some of the most important design ideas.
    Opinion
  12. @joehall22.bsky.social

    Something that is rarely discussed with vibe coding: LLMs have a bias towards the same absolutist mindset that is often seen on online forums like stackoverflow. This results in application architecture design without a lot of nuance. Especially when your prompt doesn't give sufficient context. 1/2

    Opinion
  13. The use of AI & its associated technologies in the labour market is a classic collective action problem. When one person uses AI to help refine/improve their application, they can gain some extra traction in the application process....when everyone does all it does its impose costs on applicants (of more rejections); and employers meeting more capacity to assess applications in the face of the AI-engineered torrent. Once again as @pluralistic would point out - enshifification #AI #workers

    Opinion
  14. @coil.bsky.social

    "The dominant activity becomes not making, but preventing the system from producing something mediocre." Would you rather work your way to the right answer or stand in front of a conveyor belt, rejecting an endless stream of wrong answers till a "close enough" comes along?

    3. Depletion The designer who remains employed after the restructuring of the last few years now works inside a specific arrangement, in fewer in number, responsible for more surface area, equipped with tools that generate output at a rate that exceeds any single person's capacity to evaluate it critically. Brian Eno described this arrangement in 2025: the dominant activity becomes not making but preventing the system from producing something mediocre. "You really feel the pull of the averaging effect of AI", Eno said. The cognitive load of continuous resistance, the ongoing work of refusing what the model offers and substituting it with something better, is not lighter than the load of making. It is the same load, applied to a larger volume of material, with less support.
    Opinion
  15. We came across an advert for Google’s AI thing today. The advert was about how it can make it easy to book a diverting side trip while planning a holiday. Why would I want to use that? The act of researching a holiday is part of the anticipation and enjoyment. I like to read reviews and explore possibilities. That’s what the AI pushers don’t understand. I like to write music, I like to write poetry and prose. I like to plan holidays. Taking away the process of creation is not useful.

    Opinion
  16. @gimmechocolate@bark.lgbt
    Content warningAI in GNOME

    discourse.gnome.org/t/rfc-poli… I feel like zhis guy really accidentally sums up zhe whole issue wizh what can be paraphrased as "We can't ban ai because we're controlled by corporations, and it'd make corporate-sponsored vibecoders sad." Zhe people who run zhe orgs never seam to realize it's explicitly a choice between human maintainers and vibecoders. You can't just allow people to spam slop (and every single ai user zhinks zhey're zhe one ai user who doesn't spam slop) at maintainers and eveyrone else, zhen expect non-ai users to keep working on zhe pawject. FOSS can never be people first if it keeps trying to appease corporations and zhe fragile feelings of vibecoders.

    Opinion
  17. Yes, coding agents can create a lot of code very quickly. The mistake is thinking we should do bigger releases because of it. It doesn't matter how fast you can make guesses of a random 6-digit number if you're trying to guess all 6 digits at a time. The person guessing 1 digit at a time will get it first.

    Opinion

More in AI

The model is less sure these belong here, so they sit outside the ranking.

  • I have been mostly off the grid today. So I had some time to mull over yesterday before coming back online. There are many critical voices in my feed. They make good points about financial incentives, environmental impact, etc. However, I am still in a state of positive shock. Terence Tao remarked in an interview that the age of heroes is over. I am taking away the opposite from this huge accomplishment in the very human endeavor called mathematics:

    Show more of this post

    * Levent Alpöge has joined the rank of mathematical legends. On top of persistence, what he accomplished required _skill_, for the lack of a more specific description. * LLMs are contributing to the benefit of mankind. They do not perform mathematics in the narrow sense. But by breaking the four-minute mile, they blaze the trail for human mathematicians. Or in Hilbert's words: 'Wir müssen wissen, wir werden wissen'. * There is plenty of glory left for human mathematicians from here on out. In my own words, mathematics is about finding the right abstractions, about making complex things simple. I dream of a future where someone with a solid undergraduate education in maths understands the proof of the Riemann hypothesis.

    Opinion
  • @Milkman76@syzito.xyz

    So.... for the longest time now (14ish years?), the slang term 'Clankers'(pejorative against droids in star wars movies) has been adopted by actual nazis when using codified, 'dog whistle' speech toward other nazis, very often heard in Star Wars Battlefront online games. I've been there, watching it happen. They say "destroy all clankers, but with a hard 'R'", to reference the N word, hard R. Now folks are using Clanker to describe "AI" opposition. Careful. Associations are important.

    Opinion
  • So.... for the longest time now (14ish years?), the slang term 'Clankers'(pejorative against droids in star wars movies) has been adopted by actual nazis when using codified, 'dog whistle' speech toward other nazis, very often heard in Star Wars Battlefront online games. I've been there, watching it happen. They say "destroy all clankers, but with a hard 'R'", to reference the N word, hard R. Now folks are using Clanker to describe "AI" opposition. Careful. Associations are important.

    Opinion
  • @jbakcoleman.bsky.social

    Tacking on To @astrokatie.com's point, there's a big difference between math proofs and things like "solving biology", "curing cancer", or "recursive self improvement". Starting with the destination and making sure it's reachable is just fundamentally different than exploring a huge search space.

    Opinion
  • @sheepflame.bsky.social

    This is not quite literally what’s happening, but it’s equivalent in enough ways to make it a valid metaphor. The underlying issue is that the brain driving an F1 car today is cyborg, only partly human, not what the car brain is made of, in this case a black box of traditional algorithms made by ML.

    Opinion
  • @misterpurple.bsky.social

    I think this is broadly accurate about the past few weeks, but the other aspect nobody is talking about is change freezes - most organisations are rushing to get all their changes in before Thanksgiving and Xmas periods.

    Opinion
  • @kornai@mathstodon.xyz

    OK, so we are past the singularity. Future historians will date this for sometime last week, with the Anthropic IPO (Wed-Thurs) and the GRH announcement (Fri). I don’t actually think that the system outages marked this, those are just a Tuesday thing…

    Opinion
  • @timkellogg.me

    there’s lots of compelling reasons for small/local models 1. privacy 2. data governance 3. independence 4. research 5. customizability i just don’t think cost is one of them. people who think so haven’t done the math they’re very exciting though

    Opinion
  • I REPEAT, IN ALL CAPS, TO HELP SOME READERS: THE POINT HERE IS NOT THAT THERE IS PLAGIARISM IN A SPECIFIC PROOF. THE POINT IS THAT TALKING ABOUT PLAGIARISM IN LLM RESULTS IS NOTHING SURPRISING AND, WORSE, IMPOSSIBLE TO CONFIRM IN SOME CASES, AS WE DO NOT HAVE ACCESS TO THE TRAINING DATA

    Opinion
  • More and more I become convinced we need to be tracking who in the industry has been adopting AI. Individuals. These people need to be excluded from the monumental task of un-fucking everything they’ve been a party to destroying, and from the benefits of what we rebuild. Then universal basic income, so those dumb motherfuckers don’t wreck a different industry. Or firing squads, whichever.

    Opinion
  • The barrier to aligning superintelligent systems isn't that we lack the math to write down human values—it's that humans depend on their values never being stated clearly enough to expose the contradiction between what we want our values to be and what we want to believe our values are.

    Opinion
  • @nikunj410.bsky.social

    With the AI progress in mathematics, I am reminded of a quote that I recently heard somewhere When we see a clock, of course we want to know the time, but we also want to understand how the clock works. A shift from producers to merely proctors of knowledge seems antithetical to scientific endeavor.

    Opinion
  • This also applies to "AI is here to stay!" Do a No AI DuckDuckGo search on "capitalist realism." It's about how capitalists brainwash everyone into being unable to imagine anything outside of capitalism. Capitalism has also been around for a small fraction of the history of humanity. And yet, it's destroyed much of the Earth in 150 years.

    Opinion
  • @maxp94.bsky.social

    The problem with this reasoning is that our lives are primarily made up of tasks and decisions that are not especially thrilling or inspired. You could easily justify outsourcing any one of them individually, but what’s left of us, individually and as a society, if they’re all taken away?

    Opinion
  • @glinden.bsky.social

    This is true because ultimately productivity is what fuels sustainable growth. For AI/ML, this means much more useful products that help people get stuff done, which is much harder than putting AI features all over your products whether they work well or not.

    Opinion
  • @loam-d.bsky.social

    If you don't like AI then I think this is probably good because it will be harder to raise capital to train better models and Nvidia might capitulate and use excess capacity at TSMC to make more consumer hardware. It also may mean better memory prices.

    Opinion
  • To get a handle on it, imagine someone pitching sports fans an invention that will save them the tedious work of ever having to watch any games. AI would be great at making a summary of highlights so you’d be freed from ever having watch a game live (It might even get the scores mostly right!)

    Opinion
  • Worth saying again that other systems, such as states and markets, are also not aligned with human preferences and values and produce outcomes that overpowered humans have little choice but to accept. There's plenty of this in Marx and Weber, to name but two

    Opinion
  • @gregoryawilson.com

    For which professors have been asking for decades. A lot of the "but we NEEEEEDDDD GenAI in every classroom!" crowd would be a lot quieter if higher education administrators hadn't been listening to bad faith edtech bros for the last twenty-five years.

    Opinion
  • @garrt.bsky.social

    This is a great thread (which is typical of Sonja), and it underscores the sense I've always had that students and faculty should have solidarity against the institutions they work for/are enrolled in - I've felt this from the start of my career, but being an adjunct makes certain dynamics clearer

    Opinion