Wildroot

Queries may use an external AI service. Details

Wildroot Browser

TodayStory on Bluesky

“Karl Marx predicted AI nearly 200 years ago.”

Posts
215
People
215
Time
–
Mostly
AI

215 of the story’s 317 posts, best first: one per person. We leave out exact copies and posts from people whose settings keep them off pages like this one, and in the biggest stories everything after the best 300. Page 1 of 5. The title is the name people mention most, or the opening line of the best post.

  1. @bladeofthes.bsky.social

    Karl Marx predicted AI nearly 200 years ago. He said one day the production process would be entirely automated to the point that humans weren't needed. His prediction for what would happen to the workers under Capitalism was not optimistic. He said they would be 'cast away'

    Popular today
  2. “These systems are solving problems in a few hours that I thought I’d be working on for years,” said a postdoctoral researcher in statistics. “It’s hard on the ego," Winer said. "But I’m much more concerned about the Mike-Winer-and-everyone-I-know-dying timeline.” www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/m...

    Info
  3. @jtresser.bsky.social

    One of the most insightful pieces I’ve read on AI/ChatGPT. Why wouldn’t tech that relies on consuming intellectual labor to “evolve” reflect us - global humanity - and all our entrenched biases, systems, and power dynamics?

  4. Before Google existed, someone wrote down the fix for prompt tracking. It tells you which prompts belong on your list and what a right answer looks like. Thirty years later, search still hasn't picked it up. duaneforresterdecodes.substack.com/p/the-missin...

  5. Just wanted to add that for most writers the $3K per book is split 50/50 between them and their publisher, and that *many* authors whose works were stolen aren't even included in this settlement.

    OpinionPopular todayprobably AI
  6. @lena-tech.bsky.social

    AI-generated content may be cheap to produce, but it can be expensive for others to consume, verify and correct. A linguist’s survey of the vocabulary surrounding AI slop reveals how people perceive this transfer of costs. 1/7

  7. @erikahall.bsky.social

    The thing I keep coming back to is the degree to which automation is a fantasy. So many things aren't automated as much as they are orchestrated with capital, and easily disrupted or reallocated. And the below is the most distilled "cancer is our business model" elevator pitch I've ever seen.

    Opinion
  8. @sharp.blue

    If we had an oracle that could tell us whether a particular mathematical hypothesis was true or false, mathematicians would find it boring. The interest is in the proof, and elegant and concise proofs are the most valuable.

    OpinionScience
  9. @paul4jags.bsky.social

    I see "not being a Luddite" is being worn as a badge of honour by several AI adopters who seem to misunderstand who the Luddites were and what they wanted. Here's a nice wee article from 2011, written by a human about them. Here's What the Luddites Really Fought Against share.google/hweGJwSTyMUi...

    Recommendation
  10. @kwazekwaze.bsky.social

    In some respects, AI is an outgrowth of one of my least favorite aspects of internet culture: Sharing "content" without attribution and shutting down pushback as seeking attention. Apart from it being rude, it also gave us such hits as: "memes from avowed racists are super popular with kids"

    Opinion
  11. @matthenry.fyi

    This article leans so hard on eccentric genius tropes to vouch for its subject’s credibility. Buddy, I studied Wittgenstein. I have lifetime immunity to this. www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/m...

  12. @matthewboedy.bsky.social

    Well, folks, it’s been a fun ride: “He calculated about a 50 percent chance that humans would lose control of powerful A.I. systems in the next five years; 22 percent that most people would eventually die as a result...” www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/m...

  13. @eryk.bsky.social

    I suspect the writers don’t know it but they’ve accidentally crafted a brilliant portrayal of the pre-existing mental health crises that *created* the x-risk flavor of “AI safety research.” I hope these people get help but I suspect there’s no deprogramming this cult. www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/m...

    Opinion
  14. @marcusolang.substack.com

    The frenzy over catching A.I. writing may be the latest in an older story: one not merely about tech, but about what's "human", how the definition keeps shifting, who it excludes. Today in @nytopinion.nytimes.com: "What Does It Actually Mean to Write ‘Like a Human’?" www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/o...

  15. @cjenergy.bsky.social

    Mathematical genius with intense feelings of doom. "He was 30, and he believed this was the last meaningful math problem of his career: how to make sure artificial intelligence behaved in ways humans wanted, before it became too powerful to control." He believes time is too short to control AI.

    Opinion
  16. essential read/watch by Marcus Olang’: “So ‘human’ was never a real place we were meant to reach. It’s just the word for wherever we happen not to be. Which tells us that this — the whole panic over catching A.I. — was never just about technology…” www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/o...

    Recommendation
  17. @rcmeg.bsky.social

    Respectfully, I think it's a bit disingenuous to argue that, after 3+ years of well-funded "Al literacy" pushes, huge corporate-university deals, and continued attacks against humanities and non-AI-focused social sciences, folks who are pushing back on all-in AI strategies are somehow the problem.

    Opinion
  18. @lu.is

    Generative AI is here to stay in the same way you can still buy a CO2-emitting car, build a car-requiring suburb, or sell a car that allows a human to drive 100mph. Or in the way alcohol was here to stay during, before, and after Prohibition. People (and business) like cars and booze a lot.

    Opinion
  19. @fraserc69.bsky.social

    Anthropic shouldn't just pay for work they stole, they should face a significant penalty for stealing it in the first place. They have blatantly breached copyright law in multiple regions. Laws either apply or it's a free-for-all. No rewards or get-outs for gangster organisations.

    Opinion
  20. @suscrockford.bsky.social

    "So “human” was never a real place we were meant to reach ... Which tells us that this — the whole panic over catching A.I. — was never just about technology. Perhaps it’s about how we define what “human” is in the first place." www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/o...

    Info
  21. @julialaite.bsky.social

    I'm reading @joemoransblog.bsky.social's book on sentences, and his discussion of Socrates' on sentences has unlocked for me something about the fundamental problem with GenAI. It's is very good a mimicking human sentences. But sentences are not what makes meaning, human writers & readers do...

    Opinion
  22. @amandasmith.bsky.social

    The thing is, the early days of internet were filled with skepticism & caution. I couldn’t cite websites for essays in MS or HS, Wikipedia was not an acceptable source in college, Google’s motto was “don’t be evil” to navigate the new frontier. That’s why the AI boom is nothing like early internet.

    OpinionPopular today
  23. One aphorism I remember from the collapse of the dot com bubble is, “A bubble isn’t over until everyone believes in it.” AI is very notably not that—there are wildly divergent opinions about it (everything from “useless” to “deity”). I am skeptical that this week was the start of a bubble collapse.

    Opinion
  24. Am I missing something? It's apparently OK for AI companies to ignore/bypass copyright laws (pay a paltry fine), and make trillions from stolen content, but the same rules do not apply to the general population? "Something is rotten in the state of Denmark", Shakespeare, Hamlet (Act 1, s.4) #AI

    Opinion
  25. @bassisjeremy.bsky.social

    I just want to give people an idea of what it is like teaching in the age of AI. We assess learning in different ways, homework, exams, in class activities, projects. None of these are perfect metrics for student learning, but different metrics loosely aligned. That alignment is now broken.

    Opinion
  26. Of all of the responses, the argument I think is most worth considering is "AI as cognitive carcinogen." That is, AI use will strip our ability to think, reason, be creative, etc. Need to think through the longer post, but for now: it terribly underestimates human potential and how we adapt to tech.

    Opinion
  27. "What is the alternative vision being proposed by the anti-[AI, cheat, steal] wing of academia?" I can't answer for academia, but it seems like "don't fucking [AI, cheat, steal]" would be the alternative vision.

    Opinion
  28. @brunodias.dev

    Part of what further complicates this of course is that "computer program" means several things: an abstract mathematical construct, a literal executable file, a product of a certain set of craft skills, or an economic artifact. And we don't generally have to think about the distinctions there.

    Opinion
  29. @yagandyr.bsky.social

    "AI will come for us all. It's going to be a part of everything. Why not just accept it?" The claim that artificial intelligence will permeate every domain of life, and that we should therefore simply accept it, deserves careful scrutiny.

    Opinion
  30. False references are one of the easiest things to check with deterministic code. If you are using an LLM for writing scientific publications, references should be checked against the APIs of CrossRef, DataCite, OpenAlex, or SciX before publication.

    Opinion
  31. @shaunduke.net

    Personally, I think they should have had to negotiate individually with every single author. And if they couldn't acquire the rights for every single work in the data set, they should have had to destroy the data set and start over with the works they had the rights to. But that's just me.

    Opinion
  32. @zaratustra.bsky.social

    A lot of the attraction of AI is that it can automatically bypass the service isolation that had been the norm for computing in the last 20 years Nothing communicates to anything else, except through a human - or an ai agent

    Opinion
  33. @abestew.bsky.social

    Unsurprising to discover that university management which claims no money for staff & regular academic activities are willing to waste money on genAI. More concerning is calls for universities to pay for genAI subscriptions for students as AI companies will merely ramp up the fees over time.

    Opinion
  34. Considering they were only willing to pay a minority of authors registered with the US copyright office in the first place, the whole thing was staggeringly insulting.

    Opinion
  35. What's SO ridiculous about the new anti-AI backlash against the RH proof is that it demonstrates that, for the time being at least, AI at the extremes is augmentative rather than a full replacement for humans. This should be good news for them. But rather they want to argue that it's somehow bad.

    Opinion
  36. @stchris.bsky.social

    “Prompt engineering” is nu-corporate jargon for “communicating clearly in writing.” An LLM isn’t a superintelligent machine that solves problems and also speaks human language: It’s a human-communication simulator. Period. Humans often help each other solve problems, so LLMs simulate that behavior.

    Opinion
  37. @gralefrit.bsky.social

    This is a good point. But I don’t think AI companies should pay one-off compensation to people whose property they stole. They should not have stolen that property. And if they have stolen that property, they should either pay the industry rate for ongoing usage of that property, or close down.

    OpinionPopular todayprobably AI
  38. @robp.bsky.social

    Also the claim that the proofs are "brute forced" is, itself, silly. Do they know what the size of the space of proofs is? Do they think that, even if you turned all of the world's compute on a complex proof that true brute forcing would work? If so, I have a large composite for them to factor!

    Opinion
  39. @inanedragon.bsky.social

    No, we cannot. Because generative AI is a fad. Generative AI costs more than any gains it produces, it is an ecological & economic nightmare that will absolutely ruin everything it touches in the long run. Even the few use cases that looked promising a few years ago are starting to collapse.

    Opinion
  40. 3K (1.5K if splitting with the publisher) is an insult, 20k would be an insult, there is no fair way to resolve this other than to dissolve this company and distribute all of those billions back to the people they stole from and shutter their cultural infoweapon permanently.

    Opinion
  41. @tifaret.bsky.social

    I went to an event last night and there was a small, but noticeable group of people flying this group banner. AFAIK, the event had nothing to do with AI. No AI or AI content was present. It was just friends hanging out in VRC. The issue is that there is AI *somewhere else*

    Opinion
  42. @alwayscoffee.bsky.social

    Gen AI can’t write a poem, because it’s never loved the wrong person, lost a loved one, or fallen apart. Gen AI can’t write a poem, because it has never made a mistake and felt regret—or no regret at all. It doesn’t know that some mistakes are fun. It doesn’t know joy or sorrow. It can’t make art.

    Opinion
  43. @emfaulds.com

    Can we hasten AI's demise by explaining how taking all the IP for training for free is incredibly Communist of them? (It's not, but the sort of folk outraged by the idea would happily use chatgpt et al)

    Opinion
  44. @bobthetrout.bsky.social

    The reason they always insisted that I had to take math as a history student wasn't for answering the problems, those were already solved at my level, it was for learning how to think and work through the problems

    Opinion
  45. @bigbrohem.bsky.social

    “A.I. is progressing much faster than we thought. It’s a difficult situation, and we don’t have answers. We could be heading toward a catastrophe.” "...models (have) already demonstrated a capacity for deception, cheating, blackmail and sabotage." These "geniuses" had better find a solution. Fast.

    Opinion
  46. @emajerus.bsky.social

    I don’t know if rapidly developing AI will lead to the near-term end of human life, but some hyper-smart mathematicians fear it will. They’re racing to find mathematical solutions to limit AI‘s power to harm humanity. Let’s fight for government regulation too. 1/ www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/m...

  47. @helmll.bsky.social

    Starting to sense that 'Things take time to do well and we don't want to go faster' is something humanity will war over. AI pushing a narrative of faster, optimized, more production always... at some point it's more an existential value than it is a practical thing and people kill and die for those.

    Opinion
  48. @fraying.bsky.social

    Thinking through the current moment with an internet friend and put these two ideas together for the first time: young people may be getting drawn to conversational AI because it seems safer than talking to other humans online because all they see is people being truly terrible to each other here.

    Opinion
  49. @deebeehobbs.bsky.social

    isn’t the idea of a math equation that will save humanity from AI Apocalypse a bit like the idea of an interpretation of a poem so good that it cures cancer, by which I mean: a ludic extreme of faith in one discipline to solve all problems, when interdisciplinarity is the necessary approach

    Opinion
  50. @ncaaupgip.bsky.social

    "He [Soares] says preventing AGI is most important thing humanity has ever faced; as we’ll get into later, this priority actively impedes his and his cohort’s willingness to fight against actually-existing problems with actually-existing “AI.” substack.com/inbox/post/2...