The question I’ve had without the credentials to say it publicly. When ai people refer to “proofs no one understands”, what they mean is that in response to a prompt to make a proof, an LLM emitted some text. Without analyzing the text emitted, what was proven?
TodayStory on BlueskyPage 2
“Karl Marx predicted AI nearly 200 years ago.” · page 2
More posts from this story: page 2 of 5.
Maybe it’s easy to forget, in this moment of everyone in the AI scenes trying to be as publicly clever as they can, how viciously anti-intellectual median SV culture has been. But it really still is, just at a deeper level.
AI advocates are like 'we have produced a 250 thousand page document proving the Reimann Hypothesis and nobody understands it' and I'm like yeah cool well we have a whole lot of human beings dying of needless homelessness and hunger and curable medical conditions so I do not care
"And now we’re sold a new machine—a 'humanizer' machine—to rough our English back up...so the previous machine and its believers can finally accept that we’re human. Do you see how the goal posts keep moving?" www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/o...
What I believe all non-AI-obsessed people want (including me) is PODS: Plain Old Deterministic Search. I want to enter queries, be shown things that are relevant to that query, and then make a decision about how much I trust it on my own. I am the "inference" machine, whatever that even means.
There are a lot of already successful people throwing their hat into the AI ring. Of course they do. They can afford it even if it takes over their area of expertise. Also I’m still not convinced that AI won’t fuck up your ability to think and reason. We are so cognitively fragile.
“Recognising AI rights would give private institutions unprecedented power to manufacture rights-bearing entities at scale and exacerbate an already tilted economic, political, and cultural playing field. Even if advocates of “AI consciousness” mean well, they ultimately advance perverse values…
riffing on this thread a bit but in broad agreement: i think it is unclear as yet whether the machines ate math or just transformed it. too soon to tell whether human mathematicians are obseleted or turbocharged imo
Few days ago someone was ranting on here that agents are essential for smol bean public to cut through red tape and administrative burden. When the opposite is obviously coming: the burden will only increase, specifically to stop AI agents.
AI’s ethics can be superior to ours precisely because it lacks affective consciousness. Affective neuroscience supports the view that feeling precedes reflection. We can know a rule perfectly and still feel entitled to an exception. What does the machine stand to gain?
As much as everyone thinks a cratered stock market will kill off AI as a technology, that’s a fantasy. The dot.com bust did not kill off web services or websites. Although some companies might die, AI is with us forever.
I find myself having to unlearn bad habits - many of which he describes, like writing a wary comment about what you think might broken downstream of this fix - without quite knowing how far I can go out on this new ledge before it breaks under my weight
Worth saying again that other systems, such as states and markets, are also not aligned with human preferences and values and produce outcomes that overpowered humans have little choice but to accept. There's plenty of this in Marx and Weber, to name but two
Cambridge Dictionary's 2026 word of the year is "human." Its lexicographer says AI is changing how we talk about being human, and compounds like "human-made" now mark work by people as distinct from AI. The word is being defined against the machine. 🦂 thenextweb.com/news/cambrid...
“Like everyone, I’m tremendously impressed by the lifelikeness of these systems compared to the history of earlier #AI. But the disposition of some philosophers to take seriously the question whether these things are conscious or might soon become conscious is just ridiculous. They are assuming […]
"The kind of rigor that used to be reserved for people writing avionics software or working at Bell Labs is suddenly cheap enough to pull off on an ordinary Thursday. Calling that “caring less” has the whole thing backwards."
I was in a conference this week where three different presentations had clearly used Claude and they'd barely reskinned the slides. Honestly, what that says to the audience is simply: "Fuck you. You aren't worth my best efforts."
Early in the AI assault on us all the techbros promoted a vision that all of us would be interacting w/ the world solely through the agentic means they develop. Their desire to place every human in a mirror-imaged electrified containment is because that is the their best vision of the world.
I will not editorialize on what is said here, only affirm that it crystallizes many thoughts I’ve had as an educator who evaluates academic writing as part of my job.
Fuck here we go. Mum buys Christmas decorations off Temu - its AI slop (she's learning to spot it now) Nephew's Amazon Xmas wishlist includes books that are AI slop. "But he wants them" No, he wants books of the games he enjoys, he doesn't want to be scammed on Christmas morning. He will know.
For example, the method was stolen but also published after the cutoff date for the settlement. My 3k for TWOSF is split two ways with the publisher and then my half is split with my coauthor, so I will get $750.
I don't think most AI critics seriously think AI is a fad. In fact I suspect AI fans tell themselves that so they can more easily dismiss the very real concerns its existence is causing.
this is being pushed hard in part of the quasi-religious belief in AI "super-persuaders" among its leading theorists. I like PowerPoints more button-down than Bob Newhart. I don't need or want Ralph Harryhausen in one, and I'm suspicious of people who do.
What I bring to my work on disability is decades of thinking about disability from almost every possible angle. Historical, modern, activism, caregiving, becoming and being disabled, professional caring, others I'm sure I'm forgetting. No GAI can possibly bring that to the table.
"... frankly we’ve been having to hack all of these pieces to make them school appropriate for decades.” www.edsurge.com/news/google-...
"Last week, I started cooking dinner using human feces. But what are the alternative meal plans being proposed by the anti-feces diners?" I don't know, just go back to NOT using it, like you were a week ago? This isn't some complicated riddle, dude.
I got news, those AI-generated presentation slides may look snazzier and seem more impressive, but they are less useful than the old-fashioned templated slides you fill in yourself because how snazzy looking your slides are is not a substantive part of your presentation. Using them reminds me...
My programming books also got pilfered and used in training data. I want to see Clammy Sam and that entire cohort of creeps at 'AI' companies tossed into prison for the rest of their lives. Only fair when downloading a few MP3s ruins your life in the US.
Which is why we need human translation, editing, and writing. You ever get far enough in learning another language to start tackling idioms? You ever deal with one that has zero acceptable translation?
BTW, how many 100,000s (millions) have had their copyrighted work illegally used without compensation by @anthropic.com (and OpenAI, XAI, @Google, …)? I count myself among those. Do you?
Elon Musk wants us to be nice to programs and forget that his chainsaw killed at least 700,000 actual humans so far.
But it IS just some fad, and a spectacularly dangerous one at that. It's a glorified algorithm built specifically on theft, encoded at its baselines with fascism and bigotry, and it's killing the planet [and students' critical thinking skills]. The "serious discussion" is the one that bans it.
A plea on behalf of those, like me, who lack a vernacular--please don't conclude we're robots or AI! www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/o...
“If we assign rights to these machines, the resulting power will simply accrue to those who make and control them.“ www.techpolicy.press/the-dangerou...
The Fall of Jensen Huang He ran a company called AI Nvidia Was involved in some things invidious He had "affairs" that took him down With a shady lady and POTUS Clown The AI boom may soon be bust But don't take my words on trust That's my take on Jensen Huang Who will next be left to hang?
a fairly large percentage of education is doing things in a way that doesn't quite look like their real-world version nobody thinks it's wrong to have editors, proofreaders, research assistants, &c. &c. when writing a book, yet no one will allow you to do that for your final paper
Who is going to pay for it? Venture capital money is running out. Wall St is fed up. It doesn't pay for itself. People haven't found it useful enough to bother paying what it actually costs. No one wants data centers anywhere. There's no sustainable path to growth let alone existence.
I hear about AI psychosis a lot, but I don’t think we’re talking enough about anti-AI psychosis.
i truly am baffled why people think "well everyone's using the thing built on lawbreaking at an unprecedented scale so we just can't follow the law" is a less absurd position than even the most extremist anti-AI crusaders have
so uh who wants to bet that anthropic’s fucking gigantic riemann hypothesis proof and their “rumored” P=NP proof (lol, is math just gta6 now?) are all just accidental implementations of the Falso proof system: sigtbd.csail.mit.edu/pubs/2016/pa… inutile.club/estatis/falso/ github.com/clarus/falso
"Maybe Claude is already becoming conscious and developing personhood!" hype is not an attempt to work out the ethics of using "AI" products, it is a rhetorical gambit to reduce the value of humans now
To be more direct its possible AI is not an all consuming insect god but a strange and miraculous fulfillment of the promise of the bicycle of the mind, a symbiotic amplifier of human talent and genius rather than a grey flood washing it into the gutter.
AI-generated output is a simulacrum of human endeavor. What humans can do that AI cannot is innovate. If AI sounds too much like us, we can make ourselves different.
the alternative vision is listening to students who understand they're being sold a bill of goods when their degrees are reduced to prompt engineer and personally offended when professors admit to using AI tools for grading and course development, and creating a brand and value based on real skills
while this seems a reasonable take, reducing human language to what can be captured via text and audio data simplifies and flattens it... not to mention how inherently backward looking predicting the future based on the past is
Let the AI do things that AI can be good at- be a tool with a very specific, pre-defined task that is not generative but requires a lot of bulk processing (like picking out patterns of cancer cells) and leave the research, studying, critical thinking, composition, the assessment, etc to humans.
So no, it's not human language per se, it's all the written human sources that AI companies claimed for their own and are being permitted to sell without compensation or attribution.
If you don't like AI then I think this is probably good because it will be harder to raise capital to train better models and Nvidia might capitulate and use excess capacity at TSMC to make more consumer hardware. It also may mean better memory prices.
honestly, giving everyone anthropic stole from 20k would probably be the best way to completely counteract the incoming economic collapse by injecting a massive amount of money into people who actually drive the economy, and it'd be hugely popular, which is why it's never gonna happen
No tarring or feathering, just an observation that you can already picture education without LLMs, if you were at least partially educated before about 2023.