Wildroot

Queries may use an external AI service. Details

Wildroot Browser

TodayAISimilar posts

Similar posts

@AeonCypher@lgbtqia.space

I know that most of you don't care but the claim that #Claude (an #LLM #AI) solved the #RiemannHypothesis is really a wild exaggeration on multiple levels, and people keep posting about how it means we already have #ASI. Zzzzz. First, it's not actually confirmed it solved the #MilleniumMath problem. There is a team working through it to validate the results, and it will be months before we know. Why? Because it's a 220,000 page paper to prove it. The _only_ thing we've proven is that there's a Lean compilable proof of it, which means it has to be encoded correctly. Also, the team has already demonstrated that ***significant*** portions of the proof are superfluous.

Show more of this post

Additionally, a human (a human mathematician) was heavily involved in working with Claude to come up with the proof. Finally, a human actually proved it before Claude (probably). The thing is that a human would never publish work like this, it would be embarrassing. The only reason we think a human has solved it is that Claude's proof is forcing them into premature publication. There has not, in spite of what you may have heard, been some big breakthrough in AI; we do not have #AGI. What has happened is that we have harnesses that are good at causing an LLM to loop until it finds a proof. They are convergent optimizers when given infinite tokens. Which is A HUGE ACHIEVEMENT, but the reporting on them is wildly misleading.

Opinion

3 posts close in meaning, closest first

  1. Whenever I read a mathematics textbook, I run into the same problem: the author leaves out details, apparently assuming I should already know them. (Then again, why the hell did I buy the book in the first place?) Or perhaps those missing details were revealed exclusively to his inner circle of PhD students. Well, with AI around, even they are an endangered species now. 😂 Anyway, after all these years of pursuing mathematics as a hobby, I've come to one conclusion: a university-level mathematics textbook is no walk in the park. I want to wish good luck to everyone trying to read the 17 million lines of Lean code Claude just spat out. After all these years, mathematics has finally found its nemesis: an AI that doesn't get to skip the damn steps. And oh, what a glorious day! 😂 #RiemannHypothesis

    Same collectionOpinionAI
  2. @pschwahn@mathstodon.xyz

    Yes, I get it, we are all crashing out over the supposed AI proof of the Riemann hypothesis. Does the Lean code posted by Alpöge really verify that RH is true? I bet it does! I think the probability of it sneakily exploiting a bug is really low. Do I consider RH solved? Not really - since we don't have a solution! The Lean code has not been read, let alone understood, by a human. But that doesn't mean the proof certificate is useless: at least people know that they can stop trying to disprove RH. There is the almost finished proof by Masullo, which is obviously far more valuable than the AI Lean proof.

    Show more of this post

    Reading Alpöge's remark, he seems pretty genuine and transparent about this. Sure, he can be criticized because he works for an evil tech company (I mean that without sarcasm). But he expressly didn't release a thousands-of-pages slop PDF, so why are people acting like he did, or like his contribution is worthless or didn't require effort? I trust the mathematical community that they use this situation to their advantage. Discussion is welcome!

    Same collectionAI
  3. I have been mostly off the grid today. So I had some time to mull over yesterday before coming back online. There are many critical voices in my feed. They make good points about financial incentives, environmental impact, etc. However, I am still in a state of positive shock. Terence Tao remarked in an interview that the age of heroes is over. I am taking away the opposite from this huge accomplishment in the very human endeavor called mathematics:

    Show more of this post

    * Levent Alpöge has joined the rank of mathematical legends. On top of persistence, what he accomplished required _skill_, for the lack of a more specific description. * LLMs are contributing to the benefit of mankind. They do not perform mathematics in the narrow sense. But by breaking the four-minute mile, they blaze the trail for human mathematicians. Or in Hilbert's words: 'Wir müssen wissen, wir werden wissen'. * There is plenty of glory left for human mathematicians from here on out. In my own words, mathematics is about finding the right abstractions, about making complex things simple. I dream of a future where someone with a solid undergraduate education in maths understands the proof of the Riemann hypothesis.

    Same collectionOpinionAI